Skip to content

Allopathy, Snake Oil and the Semmelweis Reflex

June 8, 2009
Clark Stanley's :en:Snake Oil :en:Liniment. Be...

Image via Wikipedia

Recently, I found myself using the word Allopathic or Allopathy.  When asked what it meant, I stumbled blindly towards the answer, ” . . . a generalization of the standard practice of medicine.”   I lucked out.  However, having looked up the word I am not inclined to use the word again.  Why?   It has to do with motivation and maturity.  People have a right to have their opinions.  You might hear them say, ” . . .  that is the way it is done and all other ways are false”.   Since the goal is to advance the efficacy our efforts we must be patient until one can demonstrate or show the value of new, different ways of restoring and maintaining our body’s vitality or in any other area of life.   With that purpose in mind, I believe using ‘Allopathy’ or ‘Allopathic’ to describe the main stream, standard way of today’s medicine or health practitioner is counter productive.  Just a useless as describing non-traditional health maintenance and renewal arts as ‘snake oil‘ et al.

(This post acknowledges and encounter with Robin 6/8/09)

Allopathy is a term coined in the early 19th century[1] by Samuel Hahnemann[2], the founder of homeopathy, as a synonym for mainstream medicine. It was used by homeopaths to highlight the difference they perceived between homeopathy and conventional medicine, and its use remains common among homeopaths. The term derives from the Greek ἄλλος, állos, other, different + πάϑος, páthos, suffering. The distinction comes from the use in homeopathy of substances that cause similar effects as the symptoms of a disease to treat patients (homeo – meaning similar). The term allopathy was meant to contrast the homeopathic approach with those conventional medical treatments that are different from or which directly counter a patient’s symptoms; hence the terms allopathic and antipathic. Homeopaths saw such symptomatic treatments as “opposites treating opposites”. However, many conventional medical treatments do not fit this definition of allopathy, as they seek to prevent illness, or remove the cause of an illness by acting on the etiology of disease.[3][4]

The term allopathic was used throughout the 19th Century as a derogatory term for the practitioners of heroic medicine,[5][6] a precursor to modern medicine that did not rely on evidence. The meaning and controversy surrounding the term can be traced to its original usage during a heated 19th-century debate between practitioners of homeopathy, and those they derisively referred to as “allopaths.”[7] The meaning implied by the label has never been accepted by conventional medicine, and is still be considered pejorative by some.[8][9] More recently, some sources have used the term allopathic, particularly American sources wishing to distinguish between conventional medicine and, say, osteopathic.[10][6][11]

History is full of examples of this kind of tension or Semmelweis reflex; rejecting the obvious benefits in favor of the norm. 

Here is a YouTube story of a breakthrough where a Doctor looks at everything ‘going on’ and recognizes the obvious. Click Here  and further with  Univera Science (Univera White Papers)

Click here to email me or leave a comment below to go further with this discussion .

The Semmelweis reflex or “Semmelweis effect” is a metaphor for the reflex-like rejection of new knowledge because it contradicts entrenched norms, beliefs or paradigms. It refers to Ignaz Semmelweis, who discovered that childbed fever mortality rates could be reduced ten-fold if doctors would wash their hands (we would now say disinfect) with a chlorine solution. His hand-washing suggestions were rejected by his contemporaries.

There is some uncertainty regarding the origin and generally accepted use of the expression.

One source defines it as “the automatic rejection of the obvious, without thought, inspection, or experiment” and attributes the expression Semmelweis Reflex to author Robert Anton Wilson.[1]

Sporadic use of the expression can be found on other webpages[2] and blogs which may or may not be mainstream. One such website attributes Timothy Leary with the following polemical definition of the Semmelweis reflex: “Mob behavior found among primates and larval hominids on undeveloped planets, in which a discovery of important scientific fact is punished” from his book The Game of Life.[3].

The expression has found way into philosophy and religious studies as “unmitigated Humean skepticism concerning causality“.[4]

Other writers define the Semmelweis reflex as: Automatic dismissal or rejection of scientific information “without thought, inspection or experiment”. [5]

 

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
Advertisements
One Comment leave one →
  1. June 14, 2009 9:07 pm

    Dear Huck PAC Network Blogger:

    Thanks for your great work in spreading the Huckabee message of limited government, American values, and free enterprise.

    We at HucksArmy are building a blogging network to help promote the best content produced by member blogs.

    About HucksArmy: We are an independent grassroots community committed to seeing common-sense government restored through electing Gov. Huckabee President as well as similar candidates.

    Our website is at http://HucksArmy.com
    Our Facebook is: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Hucks-Army/13588058967
    Out Twitter is: http://twitter.com/hucksarmy

    To submit your blog for consideration on your front-page blogroll, please email davidblp@hucksarmy.com with your: Name, Blog Title, Blog Address, Connection to Huckabee, and Main Blog Topic Focus

    Also, if you have particularly good posts please alert us so that we can highlight them. We also are interested in people who want to guest post on our main blog (we can provide links to your home blog as well).

    We look forward to hearing back from you!

    – The HucksArmy Blog Team

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: